A National survey of BOFAS members on the treatment of primary osteochondral defects of the talus

M Khan, T Ankers, J Mangwani, N Makwana

Introduction: Osteochondral defects (OCDs) of the talus were identified as a “TOP 10” research priority in foot and ankle surgery by the James Lind Alliance in partnership with BOFAS, BOA and NIHR. To develop a research strategy, the views of BOFAS members regarding OCDs of the talus were surveyed. The results are reported here.

Methods: A questionnaire concerning the presentation, investigation and management of OCDs was formulated with input from the BOFAS National Clinical Study Group and ratified by the Scientific Committee. It concerned primary OCDs of the talus that had failed non-surgical management. It was distributed to BOFAS members via email using Microsoft Forms.

Results: There were 90 responses. Data on presenting symptoms, investigations, initial management and decision making was collected. Surgical treatment was grouped according to defect size: small or large and shallow or deep. This gave 4 categories. For the purposes of the study a large defect had a width >15mm and a deep defect had a depth >5mm. For small, shallow lesions 85 respondents chose microfracture as the first line surgical treatment. For large shallow lesions 59 respondents chose microfracture, 18 chose bone marrow stimulation plus scaffold e.g. AMIC or ACIC and 6 chose bone marrow stimulation plus a biological agent e.g. cBMA or PRP. For small deep lesions microfracture was again most popular (69 respondents). For large deep lesions microfracture was chosen by 43 respondents, AMIC/ACIC by 23 and OATs by 7. Further data was collected on post op rehabilitation.

Discussion: The study demonstrates that microfracture is the most popular first line treatment for primary OCDs of the talus of any size. That said, a wide range of treatments are in practice. This information will facilitate the development of high-quality studies to identify the most appropriate evidence-based treatment for OCDs of the talus.